Tuesday, Sep 02nd

Last update:04:20:51 PM GMT

Caster Semenya Results In - Hermaphrodite

E-mail Print
Share


The results of South African athlete Caster Semenya has been leaked to the press.

According to reports in the Australian media, the medical tests have established that she has no womb or ovaries and that she also has internal testes – the male sexual organs responsible for producing testosterone.

Earlier analysis had revealed that Semenya's testosterone levels were three times the normal level for a woman.

Sigh. 

This has turned into a media circus, with a young woman at the center.  Caster has external female genitalia. Her rural family therefore raised her as a girl. So naturally she entered track and field in the women's division.  Caster did not cheat.  However, that is not the end of the story.  Caster does have an clear edge over other women in her sport.  She's is naturally pumped full of more testosterone than other female athletes. Female athletes who pump themselves with testosterone artifically are banned for doping - cheating.  So where does that leave Caster? She has naturally testosterone at levels that would get other female athletes banned as cheats.  What is fair here?

What isn't fair here is how Caster is being treated.  Her coaches failed her, and the governing body of her sport have failed her.  This whole case was handled poorly. Her coaches should have quietly verified Caster's sex before they entered her in any international races.  Her coaches knew she wasn't doping but still had a very masculine appearance. Why didn't they gently approach Caster and have her checked out?  As professional coaches they should have foreseen that her appearance plus her performance would raise eyebrows...anyone with two eyes would have questions about Caster...questions that Caster herself admits she has been dogged with her entire life.  So why put her in this position? 

The governing body of the sport has also failed.  They have allowed this to become a political and media frenzy instead of what it is, a matter of sport and fairness.  There is no way that the world should know the results of such a personal nature before the athlete.

But what now?  Strip her of her medal?  I don't know.  Caster didn't cheat.  She ran under good faith with what nature provided her.  But did she have a clear advantage over the other women on the track with her?  Yes.  The other women were running against someone who had three times the normal amount of performance enhancing testosterone percolating in their body.  Not fair to them.  Should she be required to run with men when she has been raised all her life as a woman?  No. That's not fair to Caster, who for all she knew was a very athletic woman.  This will probably end with Caster not participating in the sport she loves.  But that's not her fault, nor is it the fault of the other female athletes who complained, the fault lies with Caster's coaches who really should have known better.

It is a shame that such an intimate personal health issue has been splashed all about the media when it clearly could have been avoided. 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh

Latest Comments

From the Forum

Article Roundup

The Gosselin Divorce

News image

Jon and Kate's Divorce is finalized. And I say Finally! I'm tired of hearing the big D word - over and ...

Read more

Illinois Civil Unions Bill Approved

News image

The State of Illinois House of Representative has passed a Civil Unions Bill. The vote was 61-52! Now it heads to...

Read more

Osama Bin Hiding in Fortified Mansion In Pakistan

News image

Not living in a primitive cave, nor in the rough terrains of Afghanistan but a comfortable, yet fortified mansion just ou...

Read more

Joe the Plumber On Gays

News image

Damn! Hasn't this idiot's 15 minutes of fame over yet? Sam Weazlebacher is giving his strong opinion about Gays and ...

Read more

White Tennis Player Caroline Wozniacki Thinks Stuffing Her Bra and Shorts for a Serena Williams Impe

News image

Jealousy rears its ugly head in many forms.  Tennis player Caroline Wozniacki is so mad that she can't achieve the su...

Read more

Oil - the Biggest Lie Perpetuated on Mankind

The Swirl is in Washington DC this week trying to set the world right. We are staying a wonderful B&B. ...

Read more

Rod Blagojevich Won't Go Away

He won't lay low. He won't shut up. He won't go away. After being impeached and ousted as Illinois's Governor, ...

Read more

Louisiana Justice Resigns

News image

Finally, Keith Bardwell did a smart thing - he resigned as Justice of the Peace of Hammond, Louisiana. Last month, ...

Read more

Michele Bachmann: Another Christian Moron

Michele Bachmann is a Republican Congresswoman from Minnesota's 6th congressional district, called for "penetrating expose" on anti-Americans in Congress....

Read more